Fuel contamination and wetstock
One bad tank can put dozens of cars on recovery trucks in an afternoon. Here is who pays for what, and why your wetstock records matter more than anything else you keep.
Updated 10 November 2026. 5 minute read
In short
- Customers’ cars are a products liability claim, and that part is normally covered.
- Your own contaminated fuel and the tank clean are only covered if the policy says so.
- The cause decides who pays in the end. Samples and paperwork are how the cause is proved.
How fuel gets contaminated
- Water. Through a failed seal, a damaged fill point or a flooded chamber.
- A crossover. Diesel delivered into the unleaded tank, or the other way round.
- A problem upstream. Fuel that was already wrong when it arrived.
- Dirt and microbial growth in a tank that has not been maintained.
Three separate losses
The customers’ cars
Repairs, recovery, hire cars. This is products liability: you sold something that caused damage. A forecourt policy should cover it, and it is the part that grows fastest, because cars keep filling up until someone notices.
Your own fuel
The contaminated stock has to be removed and disposed of, and the tank cleaned before it can be used again. This is your own loss, not a liability to someone else. Some policies cover it. Many do not. It is one of the first things we check.
The trade you lose
A grade out of action for days, and customers who do not come back for a while. Whether business interruption responds depends on how the policy defines damage. Ask before it happens.
Who pays in the end
Your insurer deals with the customers first. Then the question is whose fault it was.
If the haulier put the wrong fuel in the wrong tank, or the supplier delivered a bad load, your insurer may recover what it paid from theirs. If water got in through your own fill point, the loss stays with you and your policy.
Either way it comes down to evidence: the delivery note, the driver’s paperwork, gauge readings before and after the drop, retained samples, and the time each customer filled up.
Forum fact. Do not empty or clean the tank until you have been told to. The fuel in it is the evidence.
Why wetstock records matter so much
Wetstock management is the daily reconciliation of what was delivered, what was sold and what the tanks say is left. Done properly it does three jobs for your insurance:
- It finds leaks early. A steady loss that sales cannot explain is the first sign of a failing tank or line.
- It dates the problem. If you ever claim for pollution, the records show when it started.
- It shows the insurer how the site is run. Underwriters ask how wetstock is monitored before they offer environmental cover.
What it does not do is turn unexplained losses into a claim. Shrinkage, temperature variation and meter drift are trading losses, not insured ones.
And drive-offs?
Most insurers treat a drive-off, or a customer with no means of payment, as a trading loss too. Some policies give a limited amount of cover, with conditions attached. We will tell you plainly what yours does.
This guide is general information. Whether a particular loss is covered depends on your policy wording.
Would your policy pay for your own fuel?
It is a yes or no question, and we can answer it from your schedule.
We aim to call back within the hour during office hours, Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm.